I have none of the issues you speak about. Probably boils down to what you're comfortable with. Some of the things that bothered you are things I like most about YouTube. One thing I don't like about Spotify (though YouTube is far from perfect) is their 1000 stream threshold policy that penalizes niche independent artists with deep catalogs. I like to think my subscription and streaming counts for something. Probably should just go back to Tidal but as you stated . . . the YouTube music comes with Premium. Great to have these choices though!