The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20080805004344/http://www.philly.com:80/philly/hp/news_update/26089374.html
Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
READER FEEDBACK
Was it right to flag the proposed e-mail?
Post a comment
SAVE AND SHARE

Buzz this story.



Daniel Rubin: When your name gets turned against you

Don't even start with the jokes. He's heard them all before. And he is not amused.

You're either broken or made stronger when you grow up in 1940s West Philadelphia and your last name is Libshitz.

And Dr. Herman I. Libshitz, retired radiologist, is no pushover.

Verizon is learning this the hard way.

This spring, the 69-year-old physician and his wife, Alison, were trying to upgrade the Internet service in their summer place in Rehoboth Beach, Del. They had dial-up. They wanted DSL.

When it was time to enter their user name and create an e-mail address, Verizon wouldn't let them complete the job.

This is how the doctor remembers it:

"We called their help line, and got a wonderful young man in the Philippines who told us:

" 'We can't install it because your name has - in it.' "

I asked the doctor how I was going to print that. He said, "Just say it's a word contained in Libshitz."

He'd defended his family name with his fists as a boy at 58th and Pine. He wore it proudly on his Air Force uniform during the Vietnam era when he was defending his country.

He'd displayed it on white coats at Hahnemann and Jefferson, then at Duke and Texas, where he spent most of his distinguished career, before retiring to Chestertown, Md. He'd signed it to 200 academic papers and six texts.

The doctor asked to speak with a supervisor.

What's in a name

The Libshitzes got the same answer from the supervisor, who suggested they try misspelling their last name.

That wouldn't do, either.

The couple uses Libshitz in its e-mail address with Prodigy. So there had to be some way around the rules, the two figured.

The doctor went for a third opinion. This involved a little subterfuge. He dialed the Verizon number for billing disputes.

He explained his problem, "and the first person said, 'That's outrageous,' and put me on to a second person, who said he'd never heard of such a thing."

A third supervisor, from a help line in Norfolk, Va., agreed as well, but said the only person who could help was in Tampa, and that man would have to call India to get them to change the computer code.

No one called him back.

Several days later, Libshitz received a letter from Verizon's customer-relations desk in Everett, Wash., informing him that he could not have the user name because it didn't comply with company rules.

So the couple returned the Verizon DSL kit.

"If I can't use my own name, I'm going to stay with my AT&T dial-up," the doctor said. "The hell with them."

Ten-hut!

What he wants, he says, "is for these people at least to stand at attention to explain themselves. I don't know if you've ever tried to get to Verizon. . . . You cannot get to them. They are insulated from things like this."

I called Sharon B. Schaffer, a Verizon spokeswoman, who offered a refreshing answer to my question as to how this happened.

"I don't have a clue," she said. "Actually, I'm kind of surprised. If this is Dr. Libshitz's name, your name is your identity. He's had this his entire life. . . . I think he needs a little bit of personal attention."

A couple days later, she e-mailed me a formal response:

"As a general rule (since 2005) Verizon doesn't allow questionable language in e-mail addresses, but we can, and do, make exceptions based on reasonable requests. The one from Dr. and Mrs. Libshitz certainly is reasonable and we regret the inconvenience and frustration they've been caused."

The doctor said he was willing to try again, but grudgingly:

"These people have no trouble putting me in their phone book. They send me mail with that name, they send me a bill routinely, and they cash my checks with Libshitz on it. They just offended me."


Contact Daniel Rubin at 215-854-5917 or drubin@phillynews.com.

Buzz this story.

Comments
Posted by JimmyDoDam 08:49 AM, 07/30/2008
LOL, you have to admit that is pretty funny! www.FireMe.To/udi
Posted by ghundermark 09:00 AM, 07/30/2008
First, let me preface this comment by mentioning that this story would have been far more predictable had Lipshitz been signing up for Comcast. Anyway, as the Verizon spokeswoman said, Lipshitz needs personal attention (and hopefully this story will help him out). Dealing with these phone support people often is a nightmare. For circumstances like these they are prohibited from using their judegment to override the filter that is in place. Instead of making an exception, they should update their computers to allow for their phone technicians to make this decision. This would eliminate being transferred several times, re-routed to a guy in India, and having to rely on a Verizon spokesperson to help you out. Good Luck Mr. Lipshitz. - Eric Shinn (kidding)
Posted by Tayon 09:04 AM, 07/30/2008
My teacher had the same problem. Her last name was Fuckowski.
Posted by tedinPA 09:10 AM, 07/30/2008
Well.. thank G-d he was a retired radiologist, and not a proctologist.
Posted by vrmsr 09:15 AM, 07/30/2008
This is what happens when customer service becomes an oxymoron. Verizon is too big to care about an individual as are many corporations.
Posted by onegirlinphilly 09:32 AM, 07/30/2008
verizon is rotten. they have the worst customer service. no one cares about the product or their customers for that matter. not to mention their dsl never works. the slightest hint of a storm and my dsl is on the fritz. called a million times and they tell me that there is nothing they can do about it; I'm in a low signal strength area!?!? I'm in the middle of a major metropolitan city, not appalachia!! Almost as bad as comcast....
Posted by lancer 233 09:37 AM, 07/30/2008
Doesn't the guy have a good nickname like "old f@rt"?
Posted by Mark55 09:51 AM, 07/30/2008
As usual, things get blown way out of proportion. Customer service has nothing to do with this. Do you think some schlepp on the phone is going to just fix the code to let "sh*t" appear in their email address? Do you think customer service even knows anything about how code is written? And the article states at least one person was "wonderful". The guy is sensitive to his name? Get over it.
Posted by Wilford Brimley 10:45 AM, 07/30/2008
I'm shocked he called verizon customer service and got someone who spoke english
Posted by housework 11:27 AM, 07/30/2008
I agree with Mr. Libshitz, he shouldn't have to re-arrange his name because of Verizon's CODE OF ETHICS is an insult to his proud name!!!
Posted by VAD 12:43 PM, 07/30/2008
Verizon is a bunch of scumbags. I agree with Wilford, how did he even get someone on the phone. They should not be able to do this, and if someone wants to put a "questionable word" in the e-mail, who cares. I wish another provider had FIOS, so I could cancel Verizon, their customer service is horrible!!!
Posted by Tatts 02:25 PM, 07/30/2008
One of the big problems is that they farmed the programming out to India "...would have to call India to get them to change the computer code.". This happens a lot with such outsourced programming; they may have computer knowledge, but they have no understanding--it's all literal. An American programmer would have seen the problem and coded around it with some kind of If/Then logic. He'd have done that because he lives in the US and would have known that there are names that contain strings of characters that are valid in the name but different when they stand alone. He'd know to program for the context.
Posted by Wilford Brimley 05:45 PM, 07/30/2008
diabeetis
Posted by DonQ 07:13 PM, 07/30/2008
Unbelievable! Did the Verizon people pretend that he change his name to suit their prurient tastes? Look in the phone book, and you'll find a dozen people with the last name "Colon". That's Columbus in Spanish, Verizon people!
Posted by olwgzhxtzh 10:20 AM, 08/03/2008
Two remarks: The fact that you (the author of this article) doesn't dare to print the word in question is almost as big a scandal as the original story. Secondarily, about the text of your poll ("Was it right to flag the proposed e-mail?"): you mean "e-mail address". E-mail is what you send, an address is where you send it. Or do you want to give me your phone and/or home?
  • Jobs
  • Cars
  • Real Estate
  • Rentals
Spotlight Deal
Germantown 19144
Spotlight Deal
Old City/Society Hill 19106
Spotlight Deal
Valley Forge 19403
Spotlight Deal
Chestnut Hill 19118
find an event
Mo
Aug 4
Tu
Aug 5
We
Aug 6
Th
Aug 7
Fr
Aug 8
Venue search: - by name
- by cuisine
- by venue type, e.g. "movie theater"
Location search:
- Philadelphia, PA
- 19101
- Center City
Venue search:
- by name
- by cuisine
- by venue type, e.g. "movie theater"
Location search:
- Philadelphia, PA
- 19101
- Center City
Date search:
Select which day you would like to search events, or select Search all days
Event search:
Type in the name of the event, or event type, e.g. 'live music'
SPORTS
Eagletarian: "I'm willing to admit that I've been going through a very bad time with depression," Eagles' right guard Shawn Andrews told the Daily News today. "I've finally decided to get professional help. It's not something that blossomed up overnight. I'm on medication, trying to get better."
OBITUARIES
MOSCOW - Nobel laureate Alexander I. Solzhenitsyn, the reclusive icon of the Russian intelligentsia and chronicler of Soviet repression, has died of heart failure.
Philadelphia Inquirer
What's striking about the conversation surrounding the selection of running mates for Barack Obama and John McCain is that it has generated more curiosity than passion.
AS THE FIRST anniversary of his death approaches, the smiling teenager's faded photograph remains bound with yellow crime-scene tape to a tree behind the home-plate backstop on 33rd Street near Diamond.